"A truly remarkable book ... Soaked through and through with atmosphere ... From the riches of her imagination and sympathy Miss Cather has distilled a very rare piece of literature. It stands out, from the very resistance it opposes to classification." –The New York Times
"The most sensuous of writers, Willa Cather builds her imagined world as solidly as our five senses build the uiverse around us." –Rebecca West
"[Cather's] descriptions of the Indian mesa towns on the rock are as beautiful, as unjudging, as lucid, as her descriptions of the Bishop's cathedral. It is an art of 'making, ' of clear depiction–of separate objects, whose whole effect works slowly and mysteriously in the reader, and cannot be summed up.... Cather's composed acceptance of mystery is a major, and rare, artistic achievement." –A. S. Byatt
