"Absolutely brilliant from beginning to end."–Halla Oddný Magnúsdóttir, National TV
"An amazing story . . . A very memorable reading experience, and in spite of a serious undertone there's a very finely tuned quiet humour."–Júlía M. Alexandersdóttir,
Morgunbladid "A complex and arresting novel where a super precise style and an ingenious construction come together."–Nomination Committee for the Women's Literature Prize
"Like a cubist work of art."–Jóhanna María Einarsdóttir,
DV "As her state of mind becomes increasingly fraught, Lytton Smith's adept translation skillfully conveys [the narrator's] neurotic, internal experience, which often expresses possibilities, thoughts, speculation, and interpretations instead of an external reality."–Callum McAllister,
Asymptote Journal"
History. A Mess. ... is at once a disturbing but riveting portrait of a glassy psyche and an enlightening critique of the constraints and pressures of modern scholarship."–Bailey Trela,
Ploughshares"Fans of the nouveau roman–Marguerite Duras, Alain Robbe-Grillet, Nathalie Sarraute, etc.–will be right at home here."–
Kirkus Reviews "Pálsdóttir writes with the hand of a mystery author and the mind of a postmodernist, teasing out her protagonist's problem while playing with literary forms, fragmenting timelines, and injecting fierce irony."–
Publishers Weekly "Its ambition is met with resounding success every step of the way."–Will Harris,
Books and Bao "What I admire most about Pálsdóttir's writing is her ability to hide a strictly structured course of events under a gliding, occasionally deliberately (but not distractingly) chaotic style; her ability to orchestrate the random; to construct a perspective for the narrator that, most of the time, reveals both everything and nothing about what is actually going on; and the way she covers real tensions and worries with a quilt of details, as they are so often covered in life." –Rein Raud,
European Literature Network
