"Mr. Birkin writes that he has tried to create 'a documentary account, ' not an interpretive biography. He offers such a wealth of firsthand information that the book holds up 25 years after it was first published (it was reissued last year) and becomes a rich complement to the film. Beautifully designed, the book reproduces letters and diary entries from Barrie and his circle, as well as dozens of photographs."–Caryn James, New York Times
"His most acute biographer, Andrew Birkin, whose, J. M. Barrie and the Lost Boys, has been granted a timely reissue. [It] digs up some astounding entries from Barrie's private notebooks. Some are composed in the third person, as jottings toward a possible novel."–Anthony Lane, New Yorker
"A psychological thriller . . . one of the year's most complex and absorbing biographies."–Gerald Clarke, Time
"A terrible and fascinating story."–Eve Auchincloss, Washington Post
"The best biography [of Barrie] is Andrew Birkin's."–Cathy Schultz, Daily Southtown (Chicago)
"A definitive study."–New York Daily News
"For an insightful exploration of Barrie and the boys who inspired him, nothing rivals Andrew Birkin's J.M. Barrie & the Lost Boys."–Norman Allen, Smithsonian Magazine
"[A] landmark biography."–David S. Skipper, Tallahassee Democrat
"The best [biography of Barrie]."–Matt Berman, Times-Picayune (New Orleans)