"Abbas's survey is a valiant attempt at explaining the enigma that is Afghanistan under the Taliban."–Isambard Wilkinson,
Times (UK)
"The questions [Abbas] explores are difficult and important. . . . [He] provides a well-informed survey of the second Islamic Emirate."–Steve Coll,
New York Review of Books "A fluid, readable and unique account of how their return to power has shaped the Taliban, and the possibilities that might offer for U.S. and allied policy to engage for the benefit of the Afghan people."–Shaun Waterman,
Newsweek, "Staffers' Favorite Books of 2023 for Everyone on Your Gift List"
"Compact, accessible and engrossing."–Oliver-James Campbell,
Times Literary Supplement "For Abbas, the humanitarian crisis and geopolitical issues call for talking to the Taliban, while emphasizing that such an approach 'in no way constitutes approval' of their policy."–Jean-Luc Racine,
Politique étrangère "
The Return of the Taliban adopts a distinct approach. Rather than extensively dwelling on past events, the book briefly glances in the rearview mirror, placing its primary focus on the potential for a more pragmatic and hopeful future."–Adam Weinstein,
Foreign Policy "Deeply informed. . . . Abbas sees fluidity beneath the regime's hard carapace and optimistically suggests that a Western policy of engagement could push the Taliban toward pragmatism."–Andrew J. Nathan,
Foreign Affairs "This highly readable book by Hassan Abbas is rich in revealing pivotal decisions leading to the Taliban's seizure of power and in describing how as rulers the Taliban struggle to reconcile pressures for transition with their rigid ideology. The book furnishes valuable insight into who the Taliban are and how best the West can engage them."–Marvin Weinbaum, author of
Pakistan and Afghanistan "This is a very informative and readable book, providing a comprehensive analysis of the Taliban's return to power from insurgency to governance. It succinctly traces and diagnoses the Taliban's trajectory from 1.0 to 2.0 to 3.0. Its perspective deserves to be widely read and understood."–Amin Saikal, author of
Modern Afghanistan "Hassan Abbas has written the definitive account of the Taliban's return to power in Afghanistan. The book tells a compelling story of U.S. policy failure in the region and sheds light on the inner workings of the new Taliban regime. Well-researched, rigorous and insightful, the book is a must-read for anyone interested in contemporary world affairs."–Anne Likuski, author of
Al-Qaida in Afghanistan "A nuanced, fast-paced, and vivid tale, told by a learned, wise, and compassionate scholar uniquely positioned to understand the dynamics of the Taliban's continuing evolution. Ultimately, Abbas challenges the US government to find ways to engage with the Taliban, for the good of the Afghan people, despite the misogyny, bigotry, and rigidity of their leaders."–Jessica Stern, author of
Terror in the Name of God
