"Jenny must figure out how to save the Halloween celebrations for The Cat Club when Madame Butterfly, whose performance is always the highlight of the party, loses her nose flute. Delightful tale for any age, any time of year." –Patricia Whitbeck, The Golden Notebook Bookstore, in
Booksense "I think these books about Jenny, the black Greenwich Village cat, are delightful, and the fourth in the series which started with
The Cat Club is again good fantasy, and an amusing story of how timid Jenny found she had courage to help a friend." –
Kirkus Reviews
"Told with the same mingling of gentle fun and fantasy, the same precision of prose, which has distinguished the other stories in this series." –
The New York Times
