"Coll's book is riveting." –
Richard Cohen, NY Daily News "[A] journalistic masterpiece . . . Coll succeeds on all levels . . . Coll is masterful at plumbing the depths of agencies and sects within both Afghanistan and Pakistan . . . In this era of fake news, Coll remains above it all, this time delivering an impeccably researched history of "diplomacy at the highest levels of government in Washington, Islamabad, and Kabul."
–Kirkus (starred review) "With his evenhanded approach, gift for limning character, and dazzling reporting skills, he has created an essential work of contemporary history." –
Booklist (starred review) "The most comprehensive work to date on the U.S. war in Afghanistan . . . Coll's vital work provides a factual and analytical foundation for all future work on the Afghan War and U.S. policy in Central Asia." –
Publishers Weekly (starred review)
"Spellbinding . . . It does for America in Afghanistan what Michael Gordon and Tom Ricks did for the Iraq misadventure in
Cobra II and
Fiasco." –
Evening Standard "This sequel to
Ghost Wars might well become the definitive account of the CIA and America's secret wars in Afghanistan and Pakistan . . . In the pages of
Directorate S, the sequel to Coll's Pulitzer prize-winning
Ghost Wars, the story is delivered with a literary prowess that has been absent in previous western accounts of America's longest running war. The dance of blame, with the US swaying at one moment towards Pakistan and the next towards Afghanistan, is a choreography familiar to CIA chiefs, US presidents and writers who have tackled the subject. Coll refuses to follow this tired tune, and the result is masterful." –
The Guardian "Steve Coll's
Directorate S is the sequel to his magisterial
Ghost Wars. Both books rest on a foundation of serious scholarship and Coll's extraordinary access, to individual CIA officers mostly, but also to many others. These notably included members of Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) agency, where
Directorate S was the name given to the branch of the agency "devoted to secret operations in support of the Taliban, Kashmiri guerrillas, and other violent Islamic radicals". Every assertion is carefully sourced and checked. This book is in the finest traditions of American investigative journalism. Coll is the thinking man's Michael Wolff."
–Sherard Cowper-Coles, Times of London
"Coll draws on decades of experience in South Asia, nearly 600 interviews over a decade, and thousands of pages of documents to give the most balanced and comprehensive picture to date of the unraveling of U.S. policy in Afghanistan. Few writers can match Coll's length of time on the topic, range of contacts, or personal knowledge of realities on the ground . . . it is hard to imagine a more complete and thoughtful account of how the United States went wrong in Afghanistan." –
Task & Purpose
"A spectacular account of 15 years of secret CIA and US military operations in Afghanistan and Pakistan by the investigative journalist and academic Steve Coll . . . With impressive access to American, Afghan and Pakistani intelligence, Coll reveals the extent of the surveillance undertaken by all sides . . .
Directorate S has a cast of characters that make Bourne movies pale in comparison–from type-A CIA officers and paramilitaries to cigar-smoking and whisky-drinking Pakistani generals to a dog nicknamed 'Lucky' because he was able to detect incoming missile strikes from drones before they hit."
–Financial Times
