Melville wrote oceans of prose; the poetry didn't lag far behind. Library of America [has issued] a comprehensive 1,000-page collection of that poetry, and if all you know of this marine master is
Moby-Dick, it's high time to dip your toes in the lyrical swash. –
Colin Fleming, The Washington Post One hundred years after his birth, Melville would be rediscovered on the basis of his prose. Two hundred years on, he's due for a complete reckoning. . . .
Complete Poems, edited by Hershel Parker and published on the occasion of Melville's bicentennial, should convince any reader that Melville's poetry was the coherent, sustained output of a conscious craftsman.
–The Times Literary Supplement